I love the Arabian Nights tales! Reading Guys Lit Wire last night & their list of favorite short stories I was prompted to read The Three Apples:
The story begins with governors going to the streets to ask how their officials are doing. They meet a man, very poor with no fish to bring home to his family, and bring him back to the river with the promise to buy anything he catches. He goes home happily with coins in exchange for the large chest that they pulled out of the river. Inside, in a basket of palm fronds and wrapped in a hanging, is the corpse of a fair lady. The Caliph charges Jafar to find the murderer or die in his place.
After three days Jafar is up on the scaffold to be hanged when two men approach and insist that they murdered the lady. The young man tells that his wife had been sick for many days and desired an apple, he loved her dearly so he searched and had to travel many days, but he brought her back three apples. Later he saw a slave in the marketplace tossing an apple, and the slave said that he dined with the lady and she gave him the apple. In a rage the man returned home and killed his wife, cutting her to pieces and putting her in the chest. When he returned home his son was weeping by her bed, and he told how he had taken one of the apples to play outside when a slave had walked by and beaten him up for his apple.
On hearing this tale the Caliph is again furious and charges Jafar to find the slave or die in his place. Again after three days Jafar has written his will and is saying goodbye to his family when he discovers an apple in his daughter’s pocket. It is the same apple, and he discovers that the slave is one of his own. He brings the slave to the Caliph but saves him by offering an even more impressive story than the one of the three apples that the king just witnessed in exchange for the slave’s life, the story of Nur Al-Din Ali and his son Badr Al-Din Hasan.